Case 7 (from Chapter 5): Asim Taylor

Each Case from our Book is numbered and listed here. You are welcome to discuss them. Feel free to take any side of any argument you want but remember to keep your writing civil. We will get further if we stay productive rather than destructive. And even though you may get very upset - I repeat: We will get further if we stay productive rather than destructive! Know up front that we will censor or delete if writing is beyond what we believe is civil.
Post Reply
btcbtc
Site Admin
Articles: 0
Posts: 52
Joined: Thu Jul 04, 2019 5:43 pm

Case 7 (from Chapter 5): Asim Taylor

Post by btcbtc »

Asim Taylor owes about $100,000 in child support and an appeals court in Ohio has upheld an unusual sentence meant to make sure his debt doesn’t grow bigger: Justices reaffirmed Taylor cannot have any more kids until he pays up, reports the local Chronicle-Telegram.

That means Taylor, who is in his mid-30s and has fathered four children, could go to jail if he impregnates someone during the five years he’s on probation, 19 Action News reports. He plans to appeal to the Ohio Supreme Court on the grounds he has a constitutional right to procreate, says his attorney.

The appeals court didn’t address the legal merits of the original 2013 court order, saying it didn’t have the necessary information – a pre-sentencing report – to do so, reports AP.

But one of the three judges wrote a separate opinion backing up their reasoning. “Where, as here, the defendant has demonstrated a long-term refusal to support multiple children by multiple women notwithstanding his ability to work and contribute something for their care, an anti-procreation condition is reasonably related to future criminality.”<1>

CITED REFERENCES

1. “Court forbids deadbeat dad from having more kids”
John Johnson. Newser: May 15, 2014.
Link: https://www.usatoday.com/story/news/nat ... s/9115177/ (accessed December 10, 2018).

Post Reply